Welcome to Harmony Creek, an Amish community deep in the heart of Pennsylvania. Here is an enchanted place, where Plain folk find that romance flows like the spring. While Abigail Plank is busy helping preparing the feast for the latest Harmony Creek barn raising, she gets word that someone has been injured. To her surprise, the injured one is none other than Elijah Miller. Abbie and Elijah had a secret romance during their rumspringa, which ended with Elijah breaking the poor girl's heart because she just wasn't "Amish" enough for him. But this expected meeting stirs up the past again. But when the reckless Mark Yoder makes his intentions toward Abbie clear, her life is about to turn upside-down. Mark wants to leave the Amish life and run away forever, taking Abbie with him. This could be her chance to try the outside life-a life she's always wondered about. Will Abbie try to adjust to a life and romance with Elijah, a life that she secretly wants, but can't bring herself to realize? Or will she succumb to Mark's reckless passions?