With influences ranging from jazz and prog rock to qawwali,
Sholi
's self-titled debut album is a uniquely free-flowing study in contrasts. All three of the band's members -- songwriter/guitarist
Payam Bavafa
, bassist
Eric Ruud
, and especially drummer
Jonathon Bafus
-- are fluent players and often play intricate parts, but they never feel showy; likewise,
Bavafa
's tenor is a perfect foil for the instrumentation, with a coolness that mirrors the band's prowess and emotionality that complements it.
's songs rarely end the way they started; instead, they shape-shift at will, reflecting the band's mercurial moods:
"Tourniquet"
goes from dissonant rock to melodic almost-pop and back again almost imperceptibly, with
Bafus
' busy but purposeful rhythms leading the way.
"Spy in the House of Memories"
begins with darkly twinkling, loungy jazz with a melody that could be stolen from a torch song, then melts into sunny harmonies and guitars as
sings, fittingly, "We decide what we cherish and what we forget/What we leave at the other end." These quick changes can shake listeners, especially at first, when songs like
"Out of Orbit"
and
"Dance for Hours"
feel too subtle and too insular to reveal themselves fully without close attention; fortunately,
has more immediate moments, such as the opening track,
"All That We Can See,"
which, despite its flurries of drums and guitars and stop-start structure, has a melody that remains constant and infectious, and
"Any Other God,"
which, with its martial drumbeats and subtly insistent guitars and vibes, is
's most instantly catchy song. Fortunately, even the album's least obvious moments are well worth deciphering, and the emotional connection
make on almost every track raises the band from merely impressive to very promising. ~ Heather Phares