Sheriff Lexie and Deputy Tye Wolfe are enmeshed in the strangest cases of their law enforcement careers. Two teenage girls vanish. Tye doesn't believe that Wendy is a witch. Lexie doesn't think the ocean swallowed Emma. The girls both know things that may lead to their deaths. Emma catches her stepmother with a lover. Did a family member abduct her? Wendy confronts peers about their secret activities. Perhaps her high school has a murderer or two in the student body. Tye and Lexie both know that secrets may end in murder. What they must learn, to solve their cases, is to look beyond logic to find the truth.