McKenna still has a long way to go if she's going to make the competitive gymnastics team in March. She's doing better in school, thanks to Josie's tutoring, so when Josie needs help facing her fear of horseback riding, McKenna signs up for the job. Only that causes friction with her teammate Toulane, who seems jealous of McKenna's newfound friendship with Josie. When McKenna discovers the real root of Toulane's anger, she desperately wants to help her teammate. But how can McKenna cheer on Josie at the riding center, AND support Toulane at the gym, and still work toward her own goal of making the competitive team? McKenna's torn loyalties lead to some discoveries about the power of believing in yourself and encouraging one another.