What it is: A long-wearing brow pencil with pencil-sharp precision, perfect for filling in sparse brows. Ingredient Callouts: Free of parabens and phthalates. It is also cruelty-free. What Else You Need to Know: This formula’s gel base glides on and sets for a water-resistant, long-wearing finish. The slim, oval shape allows for dimensional, hair-like strokes, while the treated pigments stay true to color all day.