Never far from the top reaches of Billboard's Country Airplay charts,
Jason Aldean
nevertheless didn't garner much attention for his latter-day slow-burning country until "Try That in a Small Town" became a controversial sensation in the summer of 2023. Accompanied by a music video shot at a Tennessee courthouse that had been the location for lynchings and race riots, "Try That in a Small Town" became a cultural lightning rod, earning scorn from progressive country music fans and being embraced by conservative audiences that helped it become the singer's first-ever chart-topper on the pop charts. All its success was based on how the single and video deliberately pushed cultural buttons; strip those away, and "Try That in a Small Town" is just another in a long line of crawling, glowering, arena-country from
Aldean
.
Highway Desperado
, the single's parent album, offers more of the same. The midtempo "Tough Crowd" attempts to get listeners prepped for a party, the midtempo "Let Your Boys Be Country" flips the old
Waylon
&
Willie
suggestion on its head, the midtempo "Whiskey Drink" carries a modicum of regret, and the midtempo "I'm Over You" soothes a broken heart with a pop pulse. Elsewhere,
co-writes for the first time in 14 years, bearing credits on the slow-moving "Hungover in a Hotel," the mildly insistent "Breakup Breakdown," and the dusty open-road anthem "Highway Desperado." That these three numbers find subtle but notable variations on
's familiar formula could be telling or it could be deliberate: it's enough to give
a fuller sound than either
Macon
or
Georgia
, even if that's hardly enough to erase the bitter taste of "Try That in a Small Town." ~ Stephen Thomas Erlewine