"Don't Stare: We Are More Alike Than You Think" follows Keyanna, a girl with a Caucasian mother and Black father, who often notices people staring at her family because they look different. Each school year, Keyanna meets classmates from other backgrounds and learns that they also experience stares for things like their food, dress, or language. Through these friendships, she discovers everyone has unique qualities and challenges.
Keyanna learns about important historical events such as the Underground Railroad, the Trail of Tears, and the Holocaust, which highlight the pain caused by prejudice and the importance of honoring diversity. Inspired by Dr. Martin Luther King Jr.'s dream, Keyanna realizes that despite differences, we are more alike than different.
Keyanna feels nervous about the transition from elementary school to junior high until she takes time to remember all the valuable lessons learned from her experiences with her elementary school classmates. The book includes reflection questions, discussion prompts, and key terms to help readers think about others' life journey.